Volunteer Attacked by Dog; Files Lawsuit Against Animal Shelter

An Orange County animal shelter is coming under flak after an incident where a former volunteer was viciously mauled by one of the dogs there. The attack lasted for roughly seven minutes, in which the victim screamed for help before being temporarily rendered unconscious.

Emily Moncur had been a volunteer at the Orange County Animal Care Facility in Tustin, and had just finished taking pictures of a dog named Blaze when the attack occurred. When she attempted to return the dog to his kennel, Blaze bit Moncur 18 times. The assault was severe enough to knock her unconscious, and resulted in grievous physical and psychological injuries.

Her attorney, John Montevideo, has stated that “the key here is about ensuring there is accountability by Orange County Animal Care,” as well as “This is a story about a preventable incident caused by a dereliction of duties that unnecessarily increased the risks of working with neglected dogs in Orange County.”

Contact Us Today

Family-founded. Trial-tested. Focused on you.

Please read our privacy policy here.

Legal Malpractice

Not every lawyer delivers the representation clients deserve. When attorneys fail to meet deadlines, provide inadequate advice, mishandle cases, or create conflicts of interest, the consequences can be severe. At Traut Firm, we are among the few firms in Orange County that specialize in legal malpractice litigation. We hold negligent lawyers accountable, helping clients recover damages for the harm caused.

Vehicle Accidents

From busy freeways to local streets, Orange County sees thousands of serious collisions each year. Our attorneys represent victims of all types of motor vehicle accidents, including:

  • Car Accidents – Fighting for compensation after distracted, drunk, or reckless driving crashes.
  • Motorcycle Accidents – Protecting riders from the unique risks they face on California roads.
  • Truck Accidents – Handling complex claims involving commercial trucks, federal regulations, and catastrophic injuries.
  • Rideshare Accidents – Navigating Uber and Lyft insurance coverage for passengers, pedestrians, and other drivers.
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Claims – Helping victims recover even when the at-fault driver lacks sufficient coverage.

Dangerous Property Conditions

Property owners are legally obligated to maintain a safe environment on their premises. When they fail, people get hurt. Our premises liability attorneys represent victims injured by hazards such as:

  • Slip and fall accidents
  • Defective stairs, steps, and handrails
  • Electrical and gas fires or explosions
  • Dog Bites

These cases often involve complex building codes and expert testimony, and we have the experience to prove liability and get justice for you.

Wrongful Death

Helping families pursue justice and financial recovery after losing a loved one.

Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI)

Life-changing head injuries requiring specialized medical and legal expertise.